After I got back from spending the day at the Muqata with Rinat and Dani, Allison called and asked me about what I'd seen and done.
One of the things I mentioned was this: I sat in the Muqata, just a few metres away from Muhammad Abu Tir, who belongs to a political party that is committed to Israel's destruction, alternately listening as the newly elected legislators were individually polled regarding a certain issue, and carrying on a conversation with a group of Israeli and Palestinian reporters.
We spoke in Hebrew. In the Muqata. Within earshot of Hamas members - many of whom also speak Hebrew, including Abu Tir.
And nobody thought this was strange. I didn't even think it was strange until I started recounting the day's events to Allison.
Lately I feel as though I keep telling the same story over and over again - just with different scenes, plot and characters. The politicians do their shtick, the media report selectively on the bits that will appeal to their readers and viewers, and behind the scenes the real story is...so different.
And the crazy thing is that hardly anyone believes me. It's really incredible - people who have never been to Ramallah warn me that it's very dangerous there.
But have you been there? I ask.
I don't need to go there! I watch the news and read the newspapers! And what about the lynch? (the invariable response).
Uh huh.
I suppose it's like a soap opera - you know, the kind that runs on for years, with people dying and new characters being introduced every so often, but nothing really changing. Not really.
My grandmother used to love the soaps. She spent hours watching them, every day. I think that she, like so many other fans of the genre, found comfort in the clearly defined roles - bad guy, good guy, evil mother-in-law, gold-digging girlfriend. No need to think, question, or analyse. The cheesy acting didn't matter.
I wish people would stop reacting to "the situation in the Middle East" as if they were watching a soap opera, and start analysing it as if it were - oh, I don't know: a Bergmann movie?
Am I being obscure, here? Or do you know what I mean?
|
|
||||||||
|
Login
This Month
Month Archive
|
As the Middle East Turns
Comments
Re: As the Middle East Turns
by
lisoosh
on Tue 14 Mar 2006 05:44 PM IST | Profile | Permanent Link
Good post. For a huge portion of the people around the world (on both "sides") who obsess about the middle east, and possibly for many who currently live there it is a soap opera. I don't know how to better show the reality and surrealness of the situation, probably by doing what you are now - telling people.
Re: As the Middle East Turns
I have to say I really appreciate being able to read about events that are happening from someone who is actually there rather than from the news. I have always hated seeing images that I can obviously see are completely one-sided.
So thanks for telling us all that you do! Re: As the Middle East Turns
by
adina
on Tue 14 Mar 2006 10:00 PM IST | Profile | Permanent Link
It is too easy to think that once you have grasped one concept, that you have captured all affiliated truths.
It is a lesson i keep having to relearn. Good post! Re: As the Middle East Turns
by
stockwell
on Tue 14 Mar 2006 10:01 PM IST | Profile | Permanent Link
Hey stranger, speaking as someone who certainly has not been to Ramallah, I definately do believe you, its that Murdochitis thing "the truth don't sell". Don't work too hard & greetings from London..
Re: As the Middle East Turns
Well written, Lisa. I got / get the same reactions from people when they hear that i spend my holidays in Israel, the "dangerous" country...thanks to the european medias ( and international medias, too ). I guess we have been talking about that last summer, during my stay in TA.
Re: As the Middle East Turns
My friend Shira encountered some problems signing up for a user account and asked me to post this comment:
lis -very good- but too little -can you elaborate? I love you for beeing so honest and "self-minded" - this is some truth that media don't feed - - tell us more! S Re: As the Middle East Turns
Has Abu Tir still got that cool orange beard, Ah Shelo, Aha?
Re: As the Middle East Turns
No, this is not a soap opera, but some ancient mythical and ritualistic dance we have all been performing since biblical times; after all, we are two peoples with long and proud histories whose collective consciousness predates ancient Egypt. The Arab-Israeli conflict is thus somewhat predictable, don't you think? Although many of us are hoping for a peaceful finale, say, like that of a torrid tango!
Trackbacks
TrackBack URL: |
|||||||














