We Media Conference - observations
I'm typing this up quickly during the conference; it's noisy and distracting here, so forgive the typos and lack of, um, cohesion... ;)
One of the things that struck me today during the conference was that the most prominent European and North American bloggers appear to be men. In the "western" world, which is the cradle of the modern feminist movement, the blogosphere appears to be mostly a boys' club. I don't read many North American female bloggers, but just off the top of my head I think mainly of women who blog about their babies (Dooce), or that woman who blogged about working her way through the Julia Child cookbook in a year (didn't she end up with a book contract in the end?).
On the other hand, when I think about my favourite Middle Eastern bloggers - the ones I read regularly because they are creative, intelligent, insightful, opinionated and daring - I realise they are mostly female. And they don't write exclusively about babies, cooking and kitty cats, either. I mean, they do write about those subjects, when they are part of their lives - but they are not the raisons d'etre for their blogs.
Neha said the same is true of the Indian blogosphere - that the best, sharpest blogs are written by women. This, from the land of arranged marriages, dowries and bride burning.
And we both noticed, too, that female bloggers are more likely to be flamed than male bloggers. That is according to our observations - if you think (or have experienced) differently, please say so in the comments.
How did it happen that two region of the world that are not exactly well known for promoting and protecting feminism have managed to produce so many serious, fearless female bloggers?
Meanwhile, one of the most famous female British bloggers writes about why her boyfriends is "a twat" (and yet a former prime minister and current head of state are women).
The United States produced Betty Friedan and Gloria Steinem ('though not a female president), but its most famous female bloggers are writing about cooking French food, raising a child (and dealing with chronic constipation) and the trials of finding a husband.
What does this mean?
|
|
||||||||
|
Login
This Month
Month Archive
|
Men, women and cultural anomalies
Comments
Re: Men, women and cultural anomalies
It means you're not reading the right blogs by American women: for example Grace Davis and Liz Henry. Grace set up the Hurricane Katrina Disaster Relief blog and Liz went to Houston with a team of yahoo techies immediately after the hurricane and live-blogged about setting up the networks at the shelter while homeland security was flailing helplessly and the police were notoriously unhelpful. They are two very results-oriented activist-bloggers. Another one is Ronnie Bennett, whose cause is anti-ageism, on Time Goes By. [Sorry I don't have links, but you can google them]
Re: Men, women and cultural anomalies
by
crosstalk
on Wed 03 May 2006 07:43 PM IDT | Profile | Permanent Link
Your observations are interesting concerning female bloggers. I'm a moderate blog reader. Of the 10-12 in the U.S. which I'm currently reading daily, the following are by females. (None of them are primarily about food or child-rearing, although the latter subject is probably
What may be interesting is that all these females are on the more-or-less conservative or libertarian side of the political divide. There may be some thoughtful female leftists over here, but none come to mind off the top of my head. Of the Middle East bloggers I read more-or-less regularly, you happen to be the only female. That said, I recognize that I am It is seldom that I even make one comment in a day, and here already I have two to your blog. You ask good questions. Re: Men, women and cultural anomalies
by
The Redhead
on Wed 03 May 2006 10:24 PM IDT | Profile | Permanent Link
Lisa, I've done a lot of thinking about this. It's not that there aren't women blogging in the US about global, political, social issues. There are. What I think is going on is that the women writing about personal stuff, like Heather of Dooce and Julie of Julie/Julia, are so wide open they get wild visceral responses from other humans. This is great in some ways - share, baby, share - but it also overshadows the women writing about politics (other than Wonkette) etc.
Most men do not share in this way, so the most popular boy bloggers are writing about programming, social networks, or the liberal media. ;) Along this line, have you met Suw yet? Re: Men, women and cultural anomalies
by
Anonymous
on Thu 04 May 2006 01:51 AM IDT | Permanent Link
It could also mean women in the Middle East and South Asia have a farther distance to go than women in Europe and North America, and blogs are a convenient tool for side-stepping institutionalized machismo in their societies.
Re: Men, women and cultural anomalies
Perhaps it is because women is developing countries, having fewer opportunities to express themselves, have more to say--while western women have had much easier access to various media (journalism, television, books) to express their most serious concerns.
Plus social change and turmoil, such as it exists in the developing world, makes for better copy than boycotting the expansion of Walmart. Re: Men, women and cultural anomalies
I would imagine that many of these female bloggers in the Middle East and India probably come from families that teach them to strive for success, families that teach them that being female shouldn't stop them from making the most of life. I'd say that it's precisely because of the way that these societies have treated their female populations that there are smart, savvy women out there making their voices heard, in what I expect is the most powerful, far reaching way for them do so, under the societal constraints.
London, eh? And here I was, kicking myself on Erev Yom Haatzmaut because I hadn't thought to invite you up to our place for a barbecue and fireworks with He and family! :-) Re: Men, women and cultural anomalies
by
adina
on Thu 04 May 2006 05:54 PM IDT | Profile | Permanent Link
I guess I do agree with you.
But I think my taste for women's stories comes from how when i read western blogs, I go for human stories about everyday life - triumphs and tragedies. Similar to my (fiction) reading taste, it is a about seeking out engaging narratives. When I seek out news on big events, however, I usually go through a collaborative filter, like boingboing (whose one female contributor, btw, gets bizarrely disproportionate flames, while the male contributors have a guru-like status). Someone I read once opined that a lot of misogyny in the 'geek' world goes unchecked because they think they are too smart to be sexist. Re: Men, women and cultural anomalies
Important bloggers? Making blogs important and too serious seems to be a boys' game, or a boys' business (with conferences on blogging, boring lectures on corporate blogs, live conference blogging with bad flickr photos or complaints about the missing wlan and so on).
You can put mostly men on your blogroll, hoping that they will accept you as one of them, or you play the sexy lady for them, or you just do your own thing. (In Germany, there's a quite new blog hype: bloggers go to blog readings - enthusiastic blog writers meet in a cafe and others come to hear their stories. Some years ago, the wannabe-serious-bloggers mocked about those "online diaries"...) Back to old school blogs: Here is a link to "pinko feminist hellcat" that I had already posted last year on a German collaborative weblog, but nobody answered or wanted to discuss about it. Perhaps the hellcat is just right :o) Re: Men, women and cultural anomalies
by
lebanon.profile
on Mon 08 May 2006 01:52 PM IDT | Permanent Link
Ann Althouse (althouse.blogspot) is a fantastic (and quite famous) blogger. She's a law professor and often writes on her subject. She also comments quite extensively on American television shows.
Re: Men, women and cultural anomalies
by
Semper Gumby
on Tue 09 May 2006 04:17 PM IDT | Profile | Permanent Link
Lisa,
I can't believe you haven't heard of Michelle Malkin and here blog plus her video blog Hotair. Essential reading. Trackbacks
TrackBack URL: |
|||||||














