See below for update.
Gen X Americans might remember a certain anti-drug commercial from the late 1980's, called "this is your brain on drugs." It showed a man who held up an egg and said, "This is your brain," before picking up a frying pan and adding, "This is drugs." He then cracks open the egg, fries the contents, and says, "This is your brain on drugs." Finally he looks up at the camera and asks, "Any questions?" As I recall, that campaign was the butt of a lot of jokes, but didn't garner the kind of publicity the Partnership for a Drug-Free America had in mind.
The Israeli anti-drug authority decided that it would be a great idea to reach out to young people with a spoof of a shaheed poster - the type one sees in the West Bank, extolling young men who have blown themselves up for "the cause." The anti-drug authority placed the following advertisement in Maariv and Yedioth yesterday. At the top it says, "The hero Omer Kendel, 16 years old, mixed vodka and ecstasy and went to blow himself
up at a party in Tel Aviv." At the bottom: "Drugs and alcohol taken
together is suicide," followed by the phone number for the anti-drug authority. The font resembles Arabic calligraphy.
I can't decide what I think about the Israeli anti-drug campaign advert. It's certainly eye-catching, but it is also racist and sensationalistic. And, of course, it's totally ineffective.
Update: Wow, just when you thought the campaign couldn't get any more tasteless - it does! According to this article on Ynet, the anti-drug authority's campaign includes a video clip styled after
the taped testaments of suicide bombers, featuring a teenager bidding
goodbye to his family telling them he is on his way to heaven. Click on the link to watch the video with English subtitles.
|
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Login
This Month
Month Archive
|
It's da bomb: new government anti-drug campaign
Comments
Re: It's da bomb: new government anti-drug campaign
by
Katherine
on Tue 19 Jun 2007 02:05 PM IDT | Permanent Link
I'm beginning to think political correctness is not something which will ever catch on in Israel :) though of course to say so would also not be politically correct....
Re: It's da bomb: new government anti-drug campaign
by
lisoosh
on Tue 19 Jun 2007 04:05 PM IDT | Profile | Permanent Link
Offensive. Not only to Arabs, but also to anyone who has lost a family member in a suicide bombing - what a horrible reminder.
And completely ineffective. Re: Re: It's da bomb: new government anti-drug campaign
by
David S
on Tue 19 Jun 2007 05:47 PM IDT | Permanent Link
Why is spoofing suicide bombers "offensive" or "racist"?
Are all Arabs suicide bombers? Suicide bombing is ripe for ridicule and satire. Re: Re: Re: It's da bomb: new government anti-drug campaign
by
JSinger
on Tue 19 Jun 2007 09:12 PM IDT | Permanent Link
Agreed. I can see where the insensitivity to victims is problematic, but the fetishization of death in shaheed posters seems entirely worthy of ridicule.
Anyway, it's brilliantly executed although I agree about its ultimate uselessness. Re: It's da bomb: new government anti-drug campaign
I think it's absolutely tasteless, for the same reasons Lisoosh mentionned.
Re: It's da bomb: new government anti-drug campaign
by
Anonymous
on Tue 19 Jun 2007 05:06 PM IDT | Permanent Link
How is this offensive to Arabs? Because it's disrespectful to their suicide bombers?
Come on. I'm asking honestly. The only thing I can think of is that it's because of the Arabic caligraphy? This is Israeli PC gone way too far. Re: Re: It's da bomb: new government anti-drug campaign
"Israeli PC?" Mwahaha. Ain't no such thing. There are, however, bloggers who think that Israeli government institutions could use a little polish and sensitivity.
Re: Re: It's da bomb: new government anti-drug campaign
by
dave
on Wed 20 Jun 2007 06:49 PM IDT | Permanent Link
Israeli PC? nope, It's the political correctness that is brought here by olim hadashim from western countries. In fact, there is hardly anything like PC here and I don't think that it's absence is a good thing. Actually, I miss it and I would welcome a bit more decency.
Anyway, I don't see any racism here, but I am neither PC nor oleh hadash from western country. As for the video
by
JSinger
on Tue 19 Jun 2007 09:18 PM IDT | Permanent Link
As for the video, I was thinking the Qassams were a bit much but that's just the MDA ad! As with the poster, the video is brilliantly executed -- they got the crummy lighting and the dazed look on the kid's face down perfectly.
Re: It's da bomb: new government anti-drug campaign
Thanks for sharing this garbage, Lisa. It is all repugnant and contemptible. Trashing anyone and everyone. You name it. No sector is spared. And I feel the ultimate fool for wasting energy typing this comment in lieu of figuring how to impact/address the real problem constructively, sanely. Who is responsible for this national health messge marketing program? What can we, your readers, do to call a HALT now?
Oh, and you look terrific in that recent photo taken in Ramallah! Re: Re: It's da bomb: new government anti-drug campaign
Eh, Tamar, maybe I have been infected by the local apathy, but I don't think there is much one can do to stop this campaign. You can call them at the phone number on the poster and complain, but don't expect them to respond with alacrity. This is Israeli bureaucracy, after all...
Re. the Ramallah photo: awwww. ;) Thank you. Re: It's da bomb: new government anti-drug campaign
by
bad vilbel
on Tue 19 Jun 2007 11:10 PM IDT | Permanent Link
I don't find this offensive to arabs (and I'm arab).
I do however find it beyond dumb. Oh, and let me get this straight: Mixing alcohol and drugs is suicide... So......if i take each separate, then it's cool! All is well :) Re: Re: It's da bomb: new government anti-drug campaign
by
Lisa Goldman
on Wed 20 Jun 2007 02:47 AM IDT | Profile | Permanent Link
BV - :D
I guess racist is not the right term for this campaign. Tacky and humourless - definitely. And dumber than dumb - for sure. Maybe I should send an email to the anti-drug folks and ask them if it's okay to take ecstasy all by itself. ;) Re: It's da bomb: new government anti-drug campaign
by
The Raccoon
on Wed 20 Jun 2007 12:14 AM IDT | Permanent Link
Uhm... how is it racist, exactly?
*sigh* Don't you think that the psychotic fashion of PC has gone way too far? Re: Re: It's da bomb: new government anti-drug campaign
by
bad vilbel
on Wed 20 Jun 2007 01:24 AM IDT | Permanent Link
If you think PC in Israel has gone too far, come spend some time in the US, Racoon! :)
Re: Re: Re: It's da bomb: new government anti-drug campaign
by
The Raccoon
on Wed 20 Jun 2007 10:12 AM IDT | Permanent Link
No thanks, man... I'll probably go berserk from an overdose of PC and bite people :)
Re: It's da bomb: new government anti-drug campaign
by
adina
on Wed 20 Jun 2007 02:45 AM IDT | Profile | Permanent Link
I don't get why they are pinpointing drugs AND booze. It seems to say that a tab of E/ a 20oz-er of vodka is fine on their own;)
I am sure this is going to launch a thousand parodies. "liquor before toke, all is ok..." This poster is lame on so many levels. Re: It's da bomb: new government anti-drug campaign
I think the poster is brilliant.
I don't find it racist at all. Re: It's da bomb: new government anti-drug campaign
by
yuyume
on Wed 20 Jun 2007 04:07 PM IDT | Permanent Link
the campaign was designed by an arts team taking field research seriously, me thinks, as in "let's try some of that stuff"...
they must have had a goooooood time Re: It's da bomb: new government anti-drug campaign
by
nominally challenged
on Wed 20 Jun 2007 11:05 PM IDT | Permanent Link
I don't see anything wrong with a drug campaign being sensationalistic. If the news can be, then I don't see why an ad shouldn't be. But racist? I can't see the racism here.
I actually find it quite funny. I mean, who of us in Israel hasn't been near or heard a suicide bomb? And yet we've developed immunity to it. And it's good that we can laugh at that. Of course, the anti-drug authority doesn't want us to laugh. They want us to be shocked. They want us to go "ohmygod! if I take drugs and drink at the same time I'll die!" But we're not shocked. We're more likely to respond along the lines of "hahaha - look! They tried to compare taking drugs to suicide bombers - how lame!" Which is of course what makes it ineffectual. Because ultimately, it won't achieve its purpose (and by omission it appears to endorse taking drugs, so long as they are not mixed with alcohol - a bit of a blunder for the "anti-drug authority", don't you think?). Re: Re: It's da bomb: new government anti-drug campaign
by
Lisa Goldman
on Thu 21 Jun 2007 01:24 AM IDT | Profile | Permanent Link
I've got no problem with making fun of suicide bombers - if the joke is funny, and intended to be funny.
This campaign is mildly amusing, IMO, only because it is stupid, and because it takes itself so seriously. You pointed out that it's pretty dumb to condemn the mixing of drugs and alcohol, thus giving the unintended impression that it's totally cool to take drugs on their own, or drink to excess as long as you don't mix the booze with pills or pot. Allison pointed out that a suicide bomber doesn't just kill himself - he kills a lot of other people as well. This campaign is about individuals killing themselves, so using a mock suicide bomber as the poster boy is pretty meaningless. If some Palestinian creative team developed an intentionally humorous advertising campaign that used - oh, I dunno - say, Israeli soldiers at a checkpoint on a hot summer's day singing for a cold Taybe beer together with the Palestinians proffering their ID cards, that could be funny. But if a Palestinian advertising company used actors dressed as hasidic Jews to advertise rat poison, I would probably find that a tad racist. Humour mostly depends on context and intention. It's pretty sad that the icon of the suicide bomber resonates so strongly around here, but hey - that's the way it is. I think the keta keta video in my next post is hilarious. I think the anti-drug campaign suicide poster boy is just totally dumb - so dumb that it's not even funny. Geez, if they'd made me laugh maybe I'd've been less offended. Re: Re: Re: It's da bomb: new government anti-drug campaign
by
David S
on Mon 25 Jun 2007 10:07 PM IDT | Permanent Link
Suicide Bomber : Hasidic Jew
Not a good analogy. Arab Man with religious garb/long beard : Hasidic Jew. Now, that's an analogy that would bolster the "racist" charge. Re: It's da bomb: new government anti-drug campaign
by
ck
on Thu 21 Jun 2007 07:21 AM IDT | Permanent Link
Lisaleh, I love you, you know that, right? So please allow me, in the most respectful way possible and as a fellow Canuck, to disagree with you. This campaign succeeds because at least people are talking about it. A lot. The analogy is also apt in so many ways - drug users in this country are supporting a criminal infrastructure that also often aids and abets terrorists, drug and alcohol abusers don't just victimize themselves, they victimize others - ie innocent car accident victims or loved ones left behind to deal with their deaths, taxpayers that have to foot the bill for their medical care etc.
The most important lesson of this campaign is something no one has noted at all. Any club kid with half a brain can tell you that alcohol diminishes the effect of ecstasy. One's an upper and the other is a downer. You're wasting your hard earned shekels if you do this and it truly is completely idiotic. So kids? Do what the poster tells you. If you're doing E, drink lots of water to prevent dehydration and stay away from the alcohol if you want those warm, fuzzy, hug inspiring feelings to last all night long. Re: It's da bomb: new government anti-drug campaign
by
Simon H
on Tue 26 Jun 2007 09:32 AM IDT | Profile | Permanent Link
Trackbacks
TrackBack URL: Weblogs that reference this article:
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||

















